Honestly this was saturated in my area around 2001. A guy started a website that was basically this ( though more "local" than "niche" really) and sold it for a nice chunk of change. I believe a radio and/or TV station bought it and it was offline within a year. The guy pumped it and got out while he could get money for it. Back then, there were a lot of suckers who would pay anything for an "internet business" with no business and spend millions on ads,etc. One local site even had an ad during the Superbowl ( for a local niche site).
I was actually publishing an offline paper back then ( as well as offering some online ad options) and used the direct mail route ( USAData, SalesGenie,etc). But I found no matter how strong my online and direct mail was, this required very good in-person closing.
Like another poster, I "went online" to avoid in person sales calls and the like. If i were a "salesman" type I would have been offline selling my ass off making huge commissions somewhere. Instead I'm online trying to make money without doing mailings, following up on leads,etc.
I'm not saying it's not a good idea. It just depends on what you are good at and your market,etc.
I was actually publishing an offline paper back then ( as well as offering some online ad options) and used the direct mail route ( USAData, SalesGenie,etc). But I found no matter how strong my online and direct mail was, this required very good in-person closing.
Like another poster, I "went online" to avoid in person sales calls and the like. If i were a "salesman" type I would have been offline selling my ass off making huge commissions somewhere. Instead I'm online trying to make money without doing mailings, following up on leads,etc.
I'm not saying it's not a good idea. It just depends on what you are good at and your market,etc.