For what you're probably paying for rent there, you could live like a literal KING in Ohio*. In a middle to upper class neighborhood. Without shit like that happening. Huge houses here in nice neighborhoods are probably less in mortgage than your rent out in FLA.
To put it in perspective, I live in a nice neighborhood out in nowheresville, ohio and only pay mid $xxx/mo. That includes utilities, not even joking. Crime rate is low because people can afford to live and don't have to resort to crime to pay bills. Sounds dirt cheap to a lot of people, but that's how things are out here. Ya, it's a noname town and not much to do, but at least it's safe and you can leave your doors unlocked and car parked on the street w/o worrying about shit like that.
In any case, getting your rims/tires stolen sucks. It isn't cheap to replace, especially on cars like that. Low life pieces of shit that do that kind of thing are usually retards who get caught eventually anyway for bigger crimes.
Good luck with the lawsuit and SEO revenge.
* - not endorsing Ohio by any means, just sayin. If I had money like you (guessing because of the sweet ride, I would be moving to the middle of nowhere pronto. City life blows.)