i'm still here... are all the gents from your WF skype roundtables still here?
Sorry, missed this one. I only have one skype group and 90% of the members are not WF guys.
Here's how I see the situation. PPC guys were always smart enough not to out traffic sources/campaigns/ads/targeting so WF turned into a SEO forum because 1) SEOs are stupid and would rather look smart to their peers than keep their mouths shut and bank hard while their exploit was working and 2) the barrier to entry to SEO is a lot lower than PPC. You can build a site on wordpress for $9 reg fee + $1/month hosting and call yourself an SEO, even tho it might never rank, but to run paid traffic, you need a pot to piss in.
So WF became SEO centric, then Google got really good at handling most greyhat SEO techniques...mostly because SEOs are stupid (me included) and discussed working tactics and exploits in front of them, as well as sold services that exploited these loopholes to other SEOs...in plain sight of the clearly lurking webspam team. And anyone who mentioned that the webspam team was monitoring our activity was derided as a tinfoil hat wearing moon landing disbeliever. Yeah, suck it fuckers, I was right. They were here and they took massive action.
So Google started playing whack-a-mole with all the exposed tactics/packages for sale while accumulating more and more data (by morons who gave it to them via the disavow tool in the interest of "fixing my site") so that each algo update they rolled out was more effective against general grey hat SEO techniques...eventually culminating in the last Penguin refresh in October '14...which you'll notice spiked the traffic drop on three forums.
Less people ranking, more people leaving for a 9 to 5 or selling local client SEO = less time to hang out on shooting the shit discussing whatever. And since the forum was predominantly frequented by SEO dumbasses, now it feels dead. What's left is either people with something to shill (CHECK OUT MY SIG BROS ITS EPIC) or the PPC guys who still come round for a laugh.
I'm sure I left some stuff out or misrepresented something but it's early and I'm only halfway thru my 1st cup of coffee so apologies there.
tl;dr WF turned into a SEO forum, SEO is dead (for the majority of people utilizing greyhat tactics), therefore WF is dead. Would be good to see a reprisal but tbh, ignoring forums and skype group chats and building digital assets is your best bet in the MMO game anyway.
tl;dr 2.0 drave was right