Full Disclosure Arbi Campaign - Niche, keyword list, ads, everything

Status
Not open for further replies.
A while back, I guess last spring I had been doing arbitrage. Had automatically generated template based pages with AdSense and I was cloaking them to make referrers from paid sources just see the ads and not the content. I was making great returns in a variety of niches (I was mining niche / keyword / price data in BULK, I mean BULK). Google wasn't happy about it. The only explanation I got was that MFA sites are not acceptable and my AdSense account was terminated. It would seem to me that any arbitrage site would count as "made for adsense" and get you terminated. The fact that people are saying it's acceptable just seems strange to me. If I can apply for another account, I may want to give this a whirl again. Ideally I'd like to get access to an Overture feed somehow, but I don't have the traffic to deal with them directly.

Duh.........they obviously checked out your site and were smart enough to use the same referrer headers that an adwords consumer would use. They come to a page with no content and only adsense ads. Adios.

If I were you, i'd start a new adsense account and put your system back online doing legit arbitrage pages with content. It sounds like you've got your framework/system thought out.
 


if your site's sole purpose is mfa, you aren't giving users something valuable and adsense really won't like you. of course what value a scraped wikipedia article has, it debatable :)
 
Great post.

Really like the idea of using a the "more forx trading" link to the affiliate product. Nice page for that too!

Btw, the link says "more forx trading" instead of "...forex..." - is that a typo or for SEO or something? (targeting the misspelling in search results??)

Take it easy, Si

hmm... niche.... forks?? :S
 
Are you guys able to get traffic from content network for smaller niches? I'll bid on 2,000 words at .05 each and get like 8 impressions for words that no one is bidding on and get at least a hundred-thousand searches a month.
 
dekalog6 awesome thread man!

thank you for walking me through this!

Its been over a month how is the "test to show how its done but not really trying campaign" going now?

Were you bale to persuade Google that the Clicks fest was fraud?

Thanks again!
 
Wow, nice post

I hadn't seen any full disclosure arbi campaign before. Thanks for showing me the ropes
 
Final disclosure for this campaign.

I thought people had forgotten about this post and moved on but people have been asking about the final outcome of this test so here are the results and what happened afterward.
Total revenue:$31.79
total adwords cost:$8.56
profit:$23.23

Yup, my Adsense CTR and profits sucked. It definitely wasn't one of my best trials. Still, I think that low number is skewed by the WF visitors going through to see the page raising the page view count. I also asked people not to click on ads to throw the profit off. My best campaigns are in the 33% to 80% range and revenues and profits are much higher. However, there are a few things different about this campaign than others. The obvious big difference was that is was public! I know WF some members took the keyword list, content, template and pretty much duplicated my campaign. Who knows how many lurkers did the same. That must have some affect on the campaign. That's fine by me, it was an open learning experience for everyone.

Google frowns upon releasing impressions, clicks, CTR and page ecpm data but I said it was full disclosure so here it is.

adwords-march-april.gif


march-april.gif


The second thing about this campaign was that I didn't do any tweaking to the ads or content during the 30 day test to improve clickthroughs. I got lazy and distracted with other projects and just left it.

What might interest you is what I did afterwards. Before I started the test I had no idea whether the forex market was oversaturated or not. From the keywords and avgCPC data in Keyword Country and this test I'm guessing it is not.

So after the 30 days was over I registered a forex domain name, set up a web site on my virtual server account, paid $12 for a newly released PLR forex article pack. I jumped on it, posted all the articles, linked, social bookmarked and pinged to get them Google indexed before the other people posted the articles to beat the Google duplicated content filter. I'm happy to say it worked. My articles are all indexed and not in supplemental. I've added older PLR articles to pad the content but those pages will likely hit supplemental.

Now after about a week, I'm getting natural search traffic clicking on Adsense without having to pay Adwords. I will have some affiliate offers tossed in there soon and will put in an RSS feed mixed with PLR articles or other content.

In some ways I'm kind of glad this didn't go huge because this is more of what you will see from a typical campaign, other than the full disclosure part. Most tests will be duds and then you will hit a big one unexpectedly. More importantly I've found arbi to be a great test marketing strategy while making money from it. I find the more tests I do the more niches I find to capitalize on in other ways whether Adsense pays me or not.

I hope some of you find this informative and useful. Feedback is appreciated.

And so it goes. I wish you success on your marketing efforts.
 
Last edited:
Final disclosure for this campaign.


In some ways I'm kind of glad this didn't go huge because this is more of what you will see from a typical campaign, other than the full disclosure part. Most tests will be duds and then you will hit a big one unexpectedly. More importantly I've found arbi to be a great test marketing strategy while making money from it. I find the more tests I do the more niches I find to capitalize on in other ways whether Adsense pays me or not.


Dekalog, thanks for sharing!

I totally agree on the educational value of going through the arbi process. I still have a ways to go to make arbi work, but the lessons are paying off in other areas.
 
dekalog If your clicks are 114 on adwords campaign then how could your adsense page show 1477 times.?
 
Because this was a full disclosure campaign. People read the post with the link to my arbi page and clicked on it to look, counting as an impression. So those were not paid clicks. That's what caused my CTR on the Adsense section to look so dismal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.