As one of the networks cited in the initial example, I have tried to stay out of this discussion. While I appreciate the heightened interest in our network as a result, my preference would have been that the thread wasn't as negative towards CX Digital as it turned into. Our experience and understanding of CX Digital has been positive in the past. I believe they deserve the benefit of the doubt. I know the advertiser (and their tracking system) well and run the offer as well, so I would guess that CX Digital was having issues with their tracking. Well, Shit Happens and mistakes are made.
Assuming no tricks were being played, I can only find fault with how CX Digital handled the situation. As a network, I understand the temptation not to proactively let your affiliates know that there is a big tracking issue as this usually results in more complaints, etc. But, affiliates are spending time/energy/money to drive traffic to these offers and deserve the information so they can decide what they should do.
As a final note, I do want to reiterate my belief in CX Digital's lack of bad intent and I am sure they will make their affiliates whole on the situation.