The more I analyze what other people are doing through ahrefs and opensiteexplorer the more I just get filled with WTF..
So many sites ranking above me that have straight trash links, shitty spun garbage on article stuffed sites with shit to do about their niche... shitty comment spam... web 2.0 with copy/paste shitty spin mentioned above..
Gotta tell myself I'm not a churn and burn operation and I'm trying to build a shining city on the hill that Google will consider the best damn website since Google.com... while I sit back and know how much $$$$ the above guys are making.
Bro, I feel you. I hate SEO for that reason.
But if Carter's new tool has taught me anything, it's that spam links + shitty content != longevity. They might be ranking/banking for a little while, but can they really maintain their position for 6+ months with a shitty backlinks profile and terrible content?
The long-term game seems to have a bigger, more satisfying payoff in the end.
Also, from what I'm able to gather (from my own sites + knowledge dropped on WF), social signals are becoming (and have been to a lesser extent) a large part of ranking. That's why many fellow faggots are now advocating a less SEO-centric approach to developing content/websites in favor of a more social one.
For this reason, I'm sticking with a 3-tier content strategy from here on out.
Tier-1: Long articles targeting primary keywords (you're already doing this). Monetize the shit out of them.
Tier-2: "Viral" type articles that can easily be shared via social. Drive traffic via ppc.
Tier-3: Shorter articles targeting low-hanging fruit kw's + juicing up your tier-1 articles (again, you seem to be doing this already). Also monetize the shit out of them.
While your Tier-1 & 3 content are waiting for Google's gooey love, you can be flooding your site with cheap ass traffic and cornering them with highly sharable content. You could even find some opportunities with raking in that Adsense skrilla. Social signals + anal traffic leakage = more exposure, SEO benefits, $$$, and an adult diaper.
Again, I'm not a fucking expert. I'm an idiot. With sometimes (theoretically) good ideas.
Anyway, good luck man. I feel you're on your way to success, whether or not you believe it. I think you just need some patience. Look forward to seeing more journal entries from you.
Stay up.