That tip is golden, it has saved me before and i hope it will save me again. As i said before, i believe it is partly scare tactics. If you keep at it even though you're failing google has to think "wow, this must be a real site not exclusively made for profit!". That's my naive, wishful thinking anywaysI will leave one tip for the duffers - don't overreact. Don't rip apart your site or do anything rash...

There is a lot of talk about googles algorithm not being "that smart"...that might be true, but the only logical conclusion would be to scare those who are smarter (humans) into making errors so the algorithm can catch them.
I just want to say one last thing to imbo: Thanks for explaining yourself, i think i understand your rage a bit better now. You don't want to be stereotyped because a bunch of noobs give SEO a bad rep. That's possibly a real threat to your current or future income. I can emphasize with that and it is actually the reason why i left certain other forums. Not because i want to actually work for clients - i could not anyways as i do not posess the skills. But because my brain was bleeding from all the obvious stupidity and misinformation.
I hope this settles things, because i'd rather go back to communication that feels more constructive to me. Wether that be sharing actual data on the update or giving gay webmaster bros cyberhugs..because you know...red arrows and stuff....