All right, I have a few more things to report about these guys. I know that $4 domains are pretty damn tempting, so hopefully this will help you guys make a more informed decision.
I'm somewhat anal about private whois records, so I decided to cough up the extra $2 in the registration process for their private whois "service." It seemed to be an automatic thing, but apparently it's not. A while after running the gamut this morning with the DNS crap, I checked the whois for the domain I registered. Lo and behold, it's all my personal info. Lovely. I realize that one of the emails sent to me after registration (you get four of them) was this:
The Whois Privacy bulk update you requested on 21-OCT-2007 08:48:44 has been processed
and uploaded to the OpenSRS live system. Please review the following Results
Report and direct any inquires to OpenSRS customer support.
Sincerely,
OpenSRS
---
Non-existent or invalid domain(s) (1):
"elime's domain" .com
---
Riiight. So I click their live chat support to see what's up with this. One good thing, it loaded up pretty quick. If you ever have need to use it (I wouldn't be shocked) remember to open it in a new window. Yes, it's one of those lovely "I'll resize your entire browser to an IM size" support systems.
So I get a somewhat-literate fellow, Doug. He says the privacy should have been implemented automatically, then changes his mind after realizing the registrar needed to send out a confirmation link. So he gets them to "resend" it to my email. Click the link, confirm. Our chat ended like this:
Elijah: I'm just trying to determine if not receiving a working confirmation link was a fluke or if I can take actions in the future to avoid such an issue.
Doug B.: don't know what might of went wrong
Doug B.: I thought it was automatic until I went to the registrar
Elijah: Well, don't worry about it then. Thanks for your help.
Doug B.: Your are welcome
Doug B.: Have a god evening
Yeah. Anyways, here we are about an hour later, and the whois records still aren't private. I'm sure it's just going to take a while to kick in, but I'm seriously not holding my breath.
So here's the verdict for hostmysite.com: I would have rather dug deep into my pockets for the extra few dollars to register a domain elsewhere and have saved a shitload of time.
Ouch, sorry for the long ass post.