With all these weird rumors aside, the reasons for backing out at the were mostly the traffic issue, which just like Tyler said wasn't hidden information, we just didn't look at it as close enough as we should have in the beginning. The second reason was the content reviews that weren't owned by the site, they are owned by the authors, so if they had decided to come back and say "you can't use these" then it's their decision and we would have no choice but to remove it.
Overall, I like the site a lot, and I don't think it's worth $50k, but, that's not to say that it can't make it once the new owner changes things around. It's definitely a fixer upper that can be flipped easily for $150k after six months or less of solid work. You would also have to invest another $10k on top of the initial purchase investment for content writers, advertising/marketing, seo work, new design/layout, and some custom scripts to give it a feel that no other place has. So I do wish Tyler the best of luck selling it, and I still think he should just go through the whole process, minus the $50k investment himself and flip it when it looks and feels like a site worthy of the asking price.
If you've heard any different about the site, and why we backed out, someone is lying to you, because what I just wrote now were the only two reasons for a no go sale at the last minute.
Overall if you have the time, resources, cash and most importantly the experience of taking a fixer upper and turning it into a hot item, by all means this is for you, and if you don't, get back to work and mind your own business.