Ethics of Poisoning My Neighbor's Dog

dogdaze

New member
Jul 20, 2011
9
0
0
4:04AM PST

My next door neighbors recently got a dog (I'd say 3 months ago, but not 100% sure) and about a month ago this dog started to bark in the middle of the night at 4AM like clockwork. It's some kind of pit bull mix and I'm not really sure why a month ago it started barking at this time so consistently, but my window faces their house and I hear it every night.

About half of the time the neighbors come out and tell it to shut up, as I expect it to since they live closest to the barking dog, but the other half of the time they usually don't hear it (not sure how this is possible) and it barks for hours on end preventing me from sleeping the rest of the night.

I'm a pretty calm and reasonable human being but I also like to think I deserve some respect and rights, like getting a good night sleep and not being woken up every day at 4 in the morning. Some of you may disagree about my mental state of health after I am about to tell my plans to you, but I still must stress that I am not a fringe psychopath; but I must resort to these measures.

I have tried to talk to my neighbors. Initially they were apologetic, telling me they are sorry and would get it under control, but since then (after my 3rd time coming to their house) have been rather dismissive and non-cooperative. Thing's didn't get any better after I phoned the city and filed a complaint and had the health inspector come to their house to make sure nothing strange was going on and they now treat me with contempt and scowl at me whenever they see me.

The city didn't really do anything except make the neighbors hate me more, and I have asked people around me if barking dogs bother them, but no one besides me seems to hear it (this house is on the corner of the street and I am the only one that directly next to it). The strangest part is dealing with the city, since there are laws about this exact situations, yet instead of sending police they send a health inspector. On my follow up call telling them that the health inspector didn't solve the problem at all and just made the neighbors pissed off at me (it's obvious that I called them in), I got some mumbo jumbo to the tune of - "Hey buddy, we're in a recession right now! We've got more important things to worry about, leave us alone, there's people getting murdered in the streets and you're wasting our time complaining about a dog. Yadda yadda."

Regrettably this is my last resort: to poison my neighbor's dog.

Yes, I have tried diplomacy. I have tried sleeping facing away from the neighbor's house and used professional grade ear plugs. I'm a pretty light sleeper so I guess this is my fault in that regard. Still, I don't see any other solution to this problem. The neighbors seem to be some kind of uncivilized hillbillies that are involved in construction work, meaning they are gone during most of the day and come back exhausted to the point where they can sleep through their own dog barking through the night, and don't respect people around them.

I have done the research and figured it would be fairly simple. I would need to either buy a ton of rat poison and cook it into meatballs or just mix it in with raw meat, or soak some french bread in anti-freeze. Just for good measure and to guarantee a clean death I would probably do both. During the day that dog is chained in the back yard (and this is a miserable, neglected dog, so I think it would be a blessing for the animal), so I think I could quickly climb over the fence and do the deed while they are at work with little chance of being seen or caught while doing it.

But like I said, I still consider myself a reasonably sane person so doing something like this or being forced to these kinds of circumstances doesn't really quite align with my morals. Not to mention it would probably be pretty obvious that it was me who poisoned their dog, if they find out that the dog was actually poisoned and not died of natural causes. But what else are my options?
 


Steal the dog and find a better home for him. The dog is no doubt neglected, otherwise he would be less inclined to bark all night.

I've been where you're at, with constant barking from neighbors... I've always been able to rid any dogs I've had of bad behaviour, but other people have a high tolerance for that kind of noise.

If you're willing to kill it, at least have the decency to steal it and place it elsewhere.

Edit: Just noticed you clearly said the dog was neglected... even more reason to find a better life for him. You'll thank yourself in the end. If you do what you're planning; stand there and watch the poor thing end his miserable life twitching and suffering for who knows how long cause of the dirty chemicals you feed it.
 
My friend suggested this to me, but this is a full grown, aggressive pitbull. Besides the fact that it would require several people, would be loud and probably seen by others, this dog would probably be able to injure people. I wouldn't feel comfortable doing this or having my friends attempt it just due to the safety risk it poses.

And trust me, I feel the greatest remorse being forced to do this. I love animals and would do this under a heavy heart. But unfortunately this seems to be my only resort. Not being able to sleep 75% of the nights can really drive a person crazy, and here we are.
 
I'd find another way, but like I said: I've been in your situation. My uncle killed his neighbor (blew his head off with a 12-guage) after coming home to discover his dog had been beat to death with a shovel... he fully well admitted to letting the dog bark all the time.

In the end karma caught up with the neighbor, who probably had been driven insane like you have.

If your gonna kill it, use a gun, or score something that will make it painless (don't know where.) Antifreeze is an agonizing death and the dog probably wouldn't eat enough rat poison to fully kill him (or at least, quickly.)

Like I mentioned: you're killing the dog because of an irresponsible owner -- then making him suffer a long agonizing death to boot.
 
Is this a spam message; joined today; UN is related to the post and the post is nothing to do with marketing. This is sort of odd so my suspicions are raised. Maybe it's just me.

Anyway regarding the dog, have you wondered if maybe you live in the matrix and actually Neo 'there is no dog', after all you said you're the only one who can hear it which makes me wonder? Either that or you might be schizophrenic and you're alter ego is the dog and if that's the case poison it at your peril!

On the other hand if your psychiatrist is convinced woofy is real, how about taking your neighbors round 3 presents. A lamp post, manikin, and an old boot in hope that it might relent barking in favor of marking territory, shagging or chewing?
 
Get one of the stop barking devices. There are a million of them. Many of them are motion activated or sound.

[ame=http://www.amazon.com/Lentek-Super-Bark-Training-Device/dp/B000F78G0O]Amazon.com: Lentek Super Bark Free Pro Series Dog Training Device: Kitchen & Dining[/ame]
 
Ethics aside, isn't this illegal? And even if it weren't, you should be prepared for a lawsuit or something.
 
Not sure what I'd do, but I'd definitely post my plans publicly (which are against criminal law) on the internet.
 
If you poison the dog, the owners may wonder what happened and get blood tests done at a vet (we had a dog die, and found out it was from a rare type of mushroom that shut down the dogs liver).

Now, if they do so and find out it was a type of poison, well...who do you think they are going to look at? I mean, there's no way they'd turn their suspicions to the neighbor who has visited them several times, and also called the city on them, right?

Dumb idea.
 
What I'm Going to Tell You Is Not To Be Taken Seriously.

I've NEVER Done This or Anything Like This.

I'm just Imagining How I Would Do It If I Knew What I'm Talking About.​

What you'll need:

Poisonous mushroom for "cause of death"
Potassium cyanide for actual cause of death
Angus Steak (one or two cubes tops) - buy from a grocer, not supermarket with good record keeping.

If you use a conservative amount of potassium cyanide on a piece of steak and include some HANDTORN mushroom pieces, it'll be very hard to detect (because it'll go through the bloodstream) while killing the dog. Buy the items over three different counties in cash and wait a few days before you consider doing anything.

Also, make an alibi for yourself: If you just happen to have spent two days at a casino/hotel no one would suspect that you took at cab back to your house for the night to stop in the backyard for 5 minutes.

Again... I don't know you and this isn't real advice.
 
What I'm Going to Tell You Is Not To Be Taken Seriously.

I've NEVER Done This or Anything Like This.

I'm just Imagining How I Would Do It If I Knew What I'm Talking About.​

What you'll need:

Poisonous mushroom for "cause of death"
Potassium cyanide for actual cause of death
Angus Steak (one or two cubes tops) - buy from a grocer, not supermarket with good record keeping.

If you use a conservative amount of potassium cyanide on a piece of steak and include some HANDTORN mushroom pieces, it'll be very hard to detect (because it'll go through the bloodstream) while killing the dog. Buy the items over three different counties in cash and wait a few days before you consider doing anything.

Also, make an alibi for yourself: If you just happen to have spent two days at a casino/hotel no one would suspect that you took at cab back to your house for the night to stop in the backyard for 5 minutes.

Again... I don't know you and this isn't real advice.

too many movies?
 
Just call the cops every morning at 4 am. The neighbors will get tired of cops at their door and find another home for the dog, or figure out some other solution. It's a routine noise complaint. Also if they don't comply then they'll get ticketed and have to pay a fine.

Also, not sure if you have a neighborhood association group, but if you do, get all of your neighbors to complain and they can fine the noisy neighbor as well.

Killing the dog is criminal and people have been locked up for this.
 
Why don't you give us your address and we can exterminate your dumb ass first, problem solved!

Seriously fucktard, call the cops.
 
Why don't you give us your address and we can exterminate your dumb ass first, problem solved!

Seriously fucktard, call the cops.

Dipshit, learn to read, he DID call the pigs. As normal, they sat on their fat asses and did nothing.
 
Asking about the ethics of this situation is going to get you a wide range of responses since it's somewhat subjective. Instead, I would focus on how to solve the problem in the best way possible. Poisoning the dog seems like a high-risk, low-reward situation with a moderate chance of getting caught since you would immediately be suspect. Instead, I would keep calling the cops when it happens while looking into other options.